Huntington Station's Neighborhood Pizzeria

Welcome to Paulie's Pizzeria, a family-owned pizzeria in Huntington Station, NY serving thin-crust New York-style pizza, pasta, heroes, calzones, salads, wings, and Italian-American favorites. From classic round pies and square Sicilian slices to parm heroes and family-friendly specials, our menu is built for dine-in, delivery, catering, and casual meals with the people you love. The menu features round pies, square pies, parm classics, pasta, chopped salads, appetizers, sides, desserts, and lunch specials.

Explore Our Menu

Hand in a black glove lifting a slice of cheese pizza from a large round pizza.

Catering

Happenings

Buffalo chicken pizza with white sauce and green herbs.

Gift Cards

Pizza night starts here

Order online from Paulie's Pizzeria for quick and easy pickup or delivery. Choose your favorite thin-crust pizza, parm hero, pasta, wings, salad, calzone, or dessert, and enjoy fresh Italian-American comfort food without the wait.

Order Online

How was your experience?

Leave a Review

$15 Regular Pie

Finally great pizza in the Huntington Greenlawn area. Growing up in Brooklyn I always had the best pizza, but after trying countless places, nothing came close. I can finally say that I found the absolute best pizza. You will not be disappointed!!!

Aaaelev

$15 Regular Pie

I was blown away with the taste of the sauce and the quality of the regular and gluten free pizza we bought for our family. From now on Paulie's is our go too Italian Pizza Restaurant!

James